[Coral-List] Economic Valuation and maket based conservation

[Steve Mussman]

Lots of interesting ideas and concepts have surfaced in 
reaction to the discussion on economic valuation as it 
relates to coral reef conservation. For sure tourism
and general economic development contribute to the problems
observed on our reefs, but isn't the obvious indifference
of societies in reaction to the degradation the real issue?

We can debate the proportionate impact of climate change,
ocean acidification, offshore drilling, agricultural practices, 
over-fishing, population growth and associated development all 
we want, but if societal indifference is the prevalent reaction
what does it matter?

Somehow we have to overcome biases and translate our collective 
concern for coral reefs into a campaign that ultimately results
in a conversion of what appears to be widespread intrinsic values 
and priorities deep-seated with apathy for this cause.

In this light, Carl's use of Deming's quote seems right on target.
("It is not necessary to change.  Survival is not mandatory.")

   
Steve