[Coral-List] Don't be Such a scientist
allison.billiam at gmail.com
Tue Jan 3 08:35:52 EST 2012
For another "don't be such a scientist" diagnosis and Rx for
influencing policy, have a look at this article:
Kassen, R. (2011). "If you want to win the game, you must join in."
Nature 480(7376): 151.
When governments ignore scientific advice, it is often because
researchers do not engage with the political process, says Rees
Scientists tend to blame poor policy decisions on a scientifically
illiterate or uninterested political class and a media that
oversimplifies ideas or sensationalizes controversy. There is no doubt
a nugget of truth here. In the current Canadian parliament, just 17 of
308 MPs hold a first degree in the natural sciences, engineering or
health sciences. If parliament reflected national university
graduation rates in these fields, there would be 98.
Still, researchers must recognize that poor scientific decisions in
politics do not necessarily result from a lack of understanding. They
are, rather, a failure of scientists to communicate their message
effectively in what is ultimately a political, not a scientific,
A former top bureaucrat in the Canadian civil service once gave me the
political perspective on this divide: scientists, he said, think too
highly of their own view of the world and fail to appreciate the
complex, multifarious nature of decision making. Our mistake is to
think that science will be given a privileged voice on an issue. This
is almost always wrong. From a politician's point of view, science is
an interest group like any other.
On Wed, Dec 28, 2011 at 8:05 PM, Gregor Hodgson <gregorh at reefcheck.org> wrote:
> David Guggenheim is to be congratulated for getting a major TV program like
> 60 minutes to focus on coral reefs with an initial viewership of over 18
> million Americans that can now be viewed online throughout the world.
> Helping to create a TV program like this takes a huge amount of time and
> effort and resources. Getting a celebrity like Anderson Cooper underwater is
> a major accomplishment because he will be talking about this experience for
> many years.
> The biggest problem facing coral reefs today continues to be the lack of
> awareness among the general public regarding how messed up coral reefs are
> and that the causes are anthropogenic I.e. fixable. David did a nice job of
> simplifying this message and this will help generate more support for coral
> reef science/ conservation efforts that are so desperately needed and
> continue to be so poorly funded.
> The underfunding of coral reef science and conservation is a reflection of
> the lack of support among the general public and politicians regarding the
> importance of this issue. The total annual funding for coral reef work
> globally wouldn¹t even pay for one beach resort in Cuba, one cruise ship or
> one high-rise office building in a major city.
> For those scientists who continue to want to nitpick ‹ I strongly suggest
> that you read the excellent book by our colleague Randy Olson on why
> scientists are such poor communicators and how we can learn to do better.
> We no longer have Jacques Yves Cousteau who was a magician at bringing the
> ocean and coral reefs into the living rooms of the average family at a time
> when there were three major TV stations. In an age of hundreds of
> TV/internet channels, we all need to try our best to better communicate the
> importance and urgency of the global decline of coral reefs and that we need
> more help to reverse this. We are winning some battles but losing the war..
> Gregor Hodgson, PhD
> Executive Director
> Reef Check Foundation
> PO Box 1057 (mail)
> 17575 Pacific Coast Highway (Fedex)
> Pacific Palisades, CA 90272 USA
> T: +1 310-230-2371 or 2360
> Gregorh at reefcheck.org
> Skype: gregorh001
> Coral-List mailing list
> Coral-List at coral.aoml.noaa.gov
Is this how science illuminates "reality"? - "the meaning of an
episode was not inside like a kernel but outside, enveloping the talk
which brought it out only as a glow brings out a haze."
- narrator's comment about Marlow's tale-telling, in Heart of Darkness (Conrad)
More information about the Coral-List