[Coral-List] Peer review in coral reef science

[John Bruno]

Hey coral reefers,

Ever wonder what other peoples reviews look like?  Want to peek behind the veil of secrecy shrouding peer-review in science?  Come on over to SeaMonster where I just posted typical reviews from our field's top journals:

http://theseamonster.net/2013/05/are-unreasonably-harsh-reviewers-retarding-the-pace-of-coral-reef-science/

Trailer:  "I think the paper is crap"   "There is no there, there"

Enjoy! And share you experiences here or there. 

JB