[Coral-List] Peer review in coral reef science

Osmar Luiz osmarluizjr at gmail.com
Thu May 23 09:28:31 EDT 2013

Maybe I'm being redundant but I've been collecting a small bibliography on the subject raised by John Bruno's post and I think it's opportune to share the references here..

Anderson M, et al. (2007) The Perverse Effects of Competition on Scientists’ Work and Relationships. Sci Eng Ethics 13:437–461
Drubin D (2011) Any jackass can trash a manuscript, but it takes good scholarship to create one (how MBoC promotes civil and constructive peer review). Molecular Biology of the Cell 22:525-527

Campanario J (1995) Commentary : On Influential Books and Journal Articles Initially Rejected Because of Negative Referees' Evaluations. Science Communication, http://scx.sagepub.com/content/16/3/304

Walbot V (2009) Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? Journal of Biology 2009, 8:24 (doi:10.1186/jbiol125)


Osmar J. Luiz 
Ph.D. Candidate
Department of Biological Sciences
Macquarie University
Sydney, NSW, 2109

e-mail: osmarluizjr at gmail.com
phone: +612 98506271
mobile: +61 0420817392
Publications list: http://publicationslist.org/osmar.luiz

On 23/05/2013, at 4:25 AM, Rebecca wrote:

> John and coral listers,
> Thanks to John for an insightful post about the issues with peer review in our field. This is a topic I often discuss with my students and postdocs. As a former ousider to coral reef work (i am a microbiologist and cell biologist by training) I was shocked by the reviews I and others in my new lab received when we began to submit to reef focused journals. Many were outright rude or personally insulting. There really should be no place for these kinds of comments in our community.  
> The result of this lack of civility is that we have a reputation among biologist for our nastiness. In an era of reduced funding but increases in collaberative science, we negatively affect our funding opportunities by creating a negative atmosphere surrounding our field. Groups that have come together to tackle big global issues are getting more funding. 
> It's so bad that many of us young coral reef biologists commonly discuss the lack of civil discourse in our field. We want to know what the root of these harsh and sometimes personal insulting reviews is? And, honestly, because many of us have toes in other fields, we avoid reef focused journals. This is a disservice to the community. 
> Yes we are a passionate bunch. And yes we care deeply about reefs. But we are also suppose to be scientists who are objective. My sense is that many reviewers forget that one's opinion and/or personal philosophy do not trump good science. We need to judge manuscripts on the overall data, the quality of the scientific procedures, and whether the conclusions are supported by the findings. We must also accept that there are limitations to what scientists can acheive in a given amount of time. There are time constraints, logistical,biological, and legal issues that cause mehodological difficulties, as well as financial limitations inherent in every project. 
> Peer review makes every published work better for the most part. But we as a community need to do a better job at removing some of the emotion from the process. 
> -becky
> On May 20, 2013, at 8:14 AM, John Bruno <jbruno at unc.edu> wrote:
>> Hey coral reefers,
>> Ever wonder what other peoples reviews look like?  Want to peek behind the veil of secrecy shrouding peer-review in science?  Come on over to SeaMonster where I just posted typical reviews from our field's top journals:
>> http://theseamonster.net/2013/05/are-unreasonably-harsh-reviewers-retarding-the-pace-of-coral-reef-science/
>> Trailer:  "I think the paper is crap"   "There is no there, there"
>> Enjoy! And share you experiences here or there. 
>> JB
>> _______________________________________________
>> Coral-List mailing list
>> Coral-List at coral.aoml.noaa.gov
>> http://coral.aoml.noaa.gov/mailman/listinfo/coral-list
> _______________________________________________
> Coral-List mailing list
> Coral-List at coral.aoml.noaa.gov
> http://coral.aoml.noaa.gov/mailman/listinfo/coral-list

More information about the Coral-List mailing list